Pubblicazioni

Autori:

Augustinus, Simone; Sijberden, Jasper P; Bieze, Matthanja; Agarwal, Vandana; Aldrighetti, Luca A; Alseidi, Adnan; Bonofiglio, Francisco C; Conlon, Kevin C P; Donadello, Katia; Erdmann, Joris; Ferrone, Cristina; Guertin, Michael; Harter, Ronald; Franceschetti, Maria E; Fusai, Guiseppe K; Groot Koerkamp, Bas; Hackert, Thilo; Jang, Jin-Young; Kander, Thomas; Keck, Tobias; Krzanicki, Dominik; Lee, Ho-Jin; Lewis, Keith; Natalini, Giuseppe; Nau, Carla; Pawlik, Timothy M; Pitt, Henry A; Reineke, Rafaella; Salvia, Roberto; de Santibanes, Eduardo; Shrikhande, Shailesh V; Smith, Martin; Szijarto, Attila; Tingstedt, Bobby; Wei, Alice C; Windsor, John; Abu Hilal, Mohammed; Pardo, Manuel; Hollmann, Markus W; Besselink, Marc G

Titolo:

Inter-rater variability for the American Society of Anesthesiologists classification in patients undergoing hepato-pancreato-biliary surgery (MILESTONE-2): international survey among surgeons and anaesthesiologists

Anno:

2025

Tipologia prodotto:

Articolo in Rivista

Tipologia ANVUR:

Articolo su rivista

Lingua:

Inglese

Referee:

No

Nome rivista:

BJS OPEN

ISSN Rivista:

2474-9842

N° Volume:

9

Numero o Fascicolo:

1

Intervallo pagine:

1-9

Parole chiave:

complications; outcome; HPB surgery; ASA

Breve descrizione dei contenuti:

Background Patients undergoing hepato-pancreato-biliary surgery are typically preoperatively assessed using the American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) classification, which is also used for case-mix adjustment when comparing centre outcomes. Studies determining the inter-rater variability of the ASA classification within hepato-pancreato-biliary surgery are currently lacking.Methods An international survey was collected and a case-vignette study was performed (November 2022-April 2023) regarding the ASA classification in patients undergoing hepato-pancreato-biliary surgery among anaesthesiologists and surgeons from (inter)national societies. The survey consisted of 23 questions and eight case-vignettes. Primary analysis included descriptive statistics and the inter-rater variability was calculated using Light's Kappa.Results Overall, 1283 participants from 55 countries responded: 1073 (84%) anaesthesiologists and 210 (16%) surgeons. The ASA classification was commonly used, both clinically 1003/1283 (78%) and for research 728/762 (96%). The majority of respondents (n = 1019, 79%) declared that ASA score impacted their perioperative strategy. There inter-rater variability was fair-moderate (Kappa 0.26-0.42) in all case-vignettes. Inter-rater variability differed within and among geographic regions for each case. Over 80% (n = 1138) of respondents stated that they would take the underlying disease (for example cancer) into account, but this changed the preferred ASA score within the case-vignettes by only 1%. Type of surgery changed the preferred score in the case-vignettes (13% difference). The most common suggestions to improve the ASA classification were to clarify whether type of operation should be considered, create a more extensive definition, and provide more examples.Conclusions Inter-rater variability was present within the ASA classification of patients undergoing hepato-pancreato-biliary surgery, which may impact perioperative strategy and hamper research results. Additional guidance to classify patients according to ASA is urgently needed. Until then, more objective measurements should be considered for case-mix adjustment within research.This is an international survey and case-vignette study including 1283 participants from 55 countries. Interrater variability regarding the ASA classification in patients undergoing HPB surgery was observed, which may impact perioperative strategy. Additional guidance to classify patients according to ASA is urgently needed. Until then, more objective measurements should be considered for case-mix adjustment within research.

Note:

The page range is based on the pdf file available in the journal website

Id prodotto:

144700

Handle IRIS:

11562/1157467

ultima modifica:

3 aprile 2025

Citazione bibliografica:

Augustinus, Simone; Sijberden, Jasper P; Bieze, Matthanja; Agarwal, Vandana; Aldrighetti, Luca A; Alseidi, Adnan; Bonofiglio, Francisco C; Conlon, Kevin C P; Donadello, Katia; Erdmann, Joris; Ferrone, Cristina; Guertin, Michael; Harter, Ronald; Franceschetti, Maria E; Fusai, Guiseppe K; Groot Koerkamp, Bas; Hackert, Thilo; Jang, Jin-Young; Kander, Thomas; Keck, Tobias; Krzanicki, Dominik; Lee, Ho-Jin; Lewis, Keith; Natalini, Giuseppe; Nau, Carla; Pawlik, Timothy M; Pitt, Henry A; Reineke, Rafaella; Salvia, Roberto; de Santibanes, Eduardo; Shrikhande, Shailesh V; Smith, Martin; Szijarto, Attila; Tingstedt, Bobby; Wei, Alice C; Windsor, John; Abu Hilal, Mohammed; Pardo, Manuel; Hollmann, Markus W; Besselink, Marc G, Inter-rater variability for the American Society of Anesthesiologists classification in patients undergoing hepato-pancreato-biliary surgery (MILESTONE-2): international survey among surgeons and anaesthesiologists «BJS OPEN» , vol. 9 , n. 1 , 2025 , pp. 1-9

Consulta la scheda completa presente nel repository istituzionale della Ricerca di Ateneo